Seaforth Highlanders of Canada Museum and Archives

Seaforth Museum - Officer's Full Dress scarlet uniform and 72nd Bn CEF uniform July 2011.
Seaforth Museum – Officer’s Full Dress scarlet uniform and 72nd Bn CEF uniform July 2011.

The Seaforth Highlanders of Canada were formed as the 72nd Regiment in 1910 and the Regiment has a proud history of service in peace and war. The Museum and Archives collect, preserve and exhibit the history of the Regiment. It earned official Canadian Forces military museum status in 2003. This UNOFFICIAL web page was created by the museum’s founder and long-time Curator, Colin Stevens.

Seaforth Museum OPEN sign January 2000,
Seaforth Museum OPEN sign January 2000,

NOTE THAT THE SEAFORTH MUSEUM IS CLOSED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE. IT WILL LIKELY REOPEN IN 2017. CHECK WITH THE SEAFORTH ORDERLEY ROOM OR SEAFORTH ASSOCIATION FOR UPDATES. I AM NOT LONGER INVOLVED WITH THE MUSEUM.

BRIEF HISTORY OF THE REGIMENT

Grave of Piper A B Thomson 72 Regt died Dec 23 1913 Civil Aid Force
Grave of Piper A B Thomson 72 Regt died Dec 23 1913 Civil Aid Force

The Regiment was formed in 1910 in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. The first known fatal casualty was with the “Civil Aid Force” (“Aid to the Civil Power” as we later called it) during the Nanaimo Strike. The 72nd Seaforths contributed thousands of officers and men during the Great War (1914-1919, now called World War I) to the Canadian Expeditionary Force units, principally to the following CEF battalions:

  • 16th Battalion (Comprised of men from 3 or 4 Regiments, including Seaforth Piper James Richardson, posthumous Victoria Cross recipient)

  • 72nd Battalion (All Seaforths)

  • 231st Battalion (All Seaforths, a reserve unit used for reinforcements to replace casualties)

The Seaforths built their own Armoury in 1936 and then turned it over to the Federal Government as I recall. In World War II the 1st Battalion Seaforth proceeded overseas and was in England before the end of 1939. They were part of the 1st Canadian Division and were crucial to the defence during the Battle of Britain. The 1st Division was finally committed to battle in the Invasion of Sicily in 1943. They fought their was through Sicily and Italy, and then were moved to Holland for the closing part of the war.

Seaforths were involved in fighting the great Fraser River Flood of 1948. During the Cold War, the Seaforths provided a complete Company for the Highland Battalion that was stationed in Germany. During the Cold War, Seaforths also served individually supplementing the Regular Army with NATO in Germany. Many Seaforths served on Peacekeeping Missions including UNEF 2 and the former Yugoslavia. A number of Seaforths were in the Battle of the Medak Pocket. Later, others went to Afghanistan. Captain Trevor Greene was famously wounded when struck in the head by an axe.

HOW THE MUSEUM WAS STARTED

About 1971-2 I found an empty cylindrical tin for 50 Players cigarettes and a Field Message Book in the drawer of the Guest Book table as one entered the Officers’ Mess. Each item had a bullet hole through it! I asked around as to their origin. The Adjutant, Captain Ron Hubner, told me that they had just been brought in. The Accession Register I created at the time recorded them thusly: “1972.22.1 and .2 Carried by Captain McIntosh. Story is that he went “over the top” in WWI with message book in one pocket of his tunic and cigarette tin in other pocket and that a German machinegun  [was] shooting at him. He was between the bullets – one bullet passing through each pocket and its contents.” Captain Hubner was drowned in a boating accident soon afterwards in March 1972. I had worked a museum in the late 1960s and I realized that if I had not recorded these stories with the artifacts, then the history would have been lost with Captain Hubner’s death. I started to search the Armoury (see below) where I found many more historic items put away and forgotten. In 1972, I talked to Major John White and got him to agree to give up the room he was using for Officers’ Kit Stores, to move the kit into the Quartermaster’s Stores, and to let me use the room to start the Museum. I have had help along the way in the form of volunteers and Museum Committee. I donated many artifacts and  my Platoon Sergeant, Sgt. Bob Adams, donated quite a few firearms to the collection.

MUSEUM

I founded the Seaforth Highlanders of Canada Regimental Museum in 1972. It has been moved a number of times in the interim, something which has greatly handicapped its progress, as so many tasks have had to be done multiple times.

  1. Originally located in the former Officers’ Kit Stores, above the Battalion Orderly Room.
  2. Later evicted after renovating that room as it was suddenly wanted as a meeting room. The Museum was moved to occupy two of the rooms of the old Janitor’s Suite located on the floor below the Officers’ Mess.
  3. Moved to an old Company Orderly Room (“C” Coy?) on the parade Square and remained there until 2012. The museum office / workroom was established in the old PPam Library off the balcony above the gym.
  4. Museum collection was placed in storage with some items on display at Jericho Garrison mid-2012 to mid-2016
  5. Museum is being relocated back in the renovated area which was its second location. 2016-2017

At the time I stepped down in 2011, the Museum Database had 7,277 items recorded. The storage was inadequate but it was basically organized with shelves all numbered and the Document and Bankers’ Boxes and Map Cabinet drawers numbered. The Museum exhibits had been inventoried, and the inventory in the storage and archives was underway with over 2,000 artifacts checked and with locations recorded.

Here are some of the most significant artifacts in the museum collection:

  • Soviet flag captured in battle by Canadians. Most Canadian do not know that Canada ever fought the Soviets, much less captured a flag. This was of national significance and not really relevant to Seaforths as only one officer served there, so it was traded to the Canadian War Museum.
  • Pilot (not prototype) model of Canada’s FIRST assault rifle, the Huot Automatic Rifle Serial number 2 (Serial #5 is the highest known). 5,000 Huots were ordered by General Currie, but the fighting ended a month later.
  • Boer War Mauser rifle named to  “L. F. BOTHA, BETHLEHEM”  It is a Sporting Model 1896, known by the Boers as a Pleizer. On the side of the butt it has the extra rare large silver escutcheon engraved with the information. and these are extremely rare as they were the most prized rifles owned by Boers. This is believed to be General Botha, one of the famous Boer Generals.
  • Parlour Pipes which appear to have originated with the Lord Seaforth in the 1700s after whom the Regiment is named. The Pipe Major handed these to me and I was able to do some basic restoration and trace the family, thus being in the days before the Internet! I made a replica tartan bag cover (no actual bag) after doing research.
  • Major General Hoffmeister’s great coat. “Hoffy” was a Seaforth of C. officer for years and quickly rose to command the 5th Canadian Armoured Division. He was also named to command the Canadian Army Pacific Force. This coat is named to him and has both 5CAD and CAPF patches on it.’
  • Battledress tunic of Lieut. Col. C. C. Merritt, V.C. from the time when he commanded the Seaforths 1951-1954.
  • Patrol Blues of Smokey Smith, V.C. which I obtained for the museum directly from Smokey’s daughter in 2011. I also obtained two others of Smokey’s uniforms from his daughter Norma-Jean. I facilitated the donation of one uniform tunic to his hometown museum in New Westminster (of which I was then Manager) and a summer uniform to the museum of the Black Watch. Smokey had rejoined the Canadian Army during the Korean War and served with the Black Watch. NOTE: The Museum did NOT receive Smokey Smith’s Victoria Cross and medals as he had specified in his Will. They were intercepted by the Regiment in 2005 and they never made it to the Museum as of July 2011. The Commanding Officer reportedly put them into a Safe Deposit box.
  • Uniform and kit of Captain Trevor Greene, worn/used in Afghanistan. It includes some items he was wearing or using that day when he was hit on the head with an axe by a terrorist. I collecting history as it happened. Some items were missing and I obtained other items from other veterans of that war. It is shown in Case 10 in the old exhibits photos.
  • Miniature model of the three figures of the Peacekeeping Monument in Ottawa. The artist who created the figures for the monument also created a few of these miniature sets for his family. Due to the family who had served with the Seaforths, this one was collected by me for the museum. It is shown in Case 10 in the old exhibit photos below. It is shown sitting on a glass shelf to the viewer’s left of Captain Greene’s Arid Cadpat uniform.  “Reconciliation” by Jack Harman.
OLD MUSEUM EXHIBITS 2008-2011 PERIOD – DISMANTLED  IN 2012 when the Seaforth Armoury was emptied for renovations and seismic upgrading. The Regiment moved back into the Armoury in September 2016.
Floorplan of the old Seaforth Museum showing numbers of display cases which are keyed to the photos below. Dismantled 2012.
Floorplan of the old Seaforth Museum showing numbers of display cases which are keyed to the photos below. Dismantled 2012.

ARCHIVES

The Seaforth Archives were started back sometime before 1946 possibly as early as the 1910s, 1920s or 1930s. The Seaforths have an incredible archives, far surpassing most Militia regiments in content. They include:

  • The original War Diaries from WWI, WWII and the Seaforth Company in Germany during the Cold War.
  • Maps
  • Photos (hundreds)
  • Diaries
  • Training Manuals
  • Reference books – Regimental histories, official Canadian war histories, relevant biographies etc.

By 1972, the Archives were stored in a room behind the bar of the Band Room on the upper floor of the armoury. The collection was carefully indexed and placed in neatly labelled file boxes. The reference books were on shelves.

The second volume of the  Regimental History was published by Dr. Reg Roy in 1965. When he finished with archival material, the boxes were returned to the Seaforth Armoury. They were then placed on the floor in the small storage room behind the Band Room’s bar. The reference books, many of them very old and rare, were on shelves.

The armoury’s heating system at the time was coal fired hot water. There was a radiator (or possibly two?)  in the room. Sadly the armoury’s roof leaked between 1965 and 1972 but no one noticed. When I found the archives the boxes of records returned by Dr. Roy were sitting in a pool of water on the floor. The water had leaked through the roof, run down the bookcase of old regimental and CEF units histories, and the radiator(s) had “super” heated the room which had no ventilation. The vast majority of the books had been soaked and then heated. Most had warped pages and covers and some were bent in half as a result. Many had pages that had “glued” themselves together. Most were too far gone to save. One large book that was not too far gone, was a history of the Imperial Seaforth’s ancestral 78th Regiment (as I recall) and due to its importance, I had it rebound and preserved.

MUSEUM OFFICE

In 1972 and for a number of years afterwards, I used a workspace for the Museum and Archives up in the Fan Room (just below the attic. Then the old Pam Library overlooking the Gym was obtained and used until 2011 August when the museum office was moved to a small room in the Association suite (old Janitor’s suite). New file cabinets were purchased and this is where donation were processed.

MUSEUM RESERVE COLLECTION (Storage)

The Fan Room on the upper floor of the armoury, opposite the Band Room and above the Anderson Room, was used for storage and as a work area. Dust was a huge problem as was crowding. Over time metal shelves and steel map cases were installed.

CURATORS

I served with the Seaforth Highlanders of Canada as an officer from 1970 to 1976 and January 1978 to March 1978, when my job took me to Saskatchewan. In 1972 I started the Seaforth Museum and served as its Curator and Archivist for about 13 years in three “tours of duty” so to speak, when my jobs and my residence enabled me to be able to come down to the armoury. In 2011 I retired from a civilian career after 40-years of working in museums, archives, national historic sites and and a national historic park. At the same time I retired from being Curator of the Seaforth Museum and Archives.

In the early 1970s I was a student at University of British Columbia, where among other subjects I took Museum Studies, History and Anthropology. I graduated with a Bachelor of Arts in 1975 and then worked from 1975 to 2011 at many museums, archives and historic sites and took extensive training in museum work during that time. I also instructed in museum work and did major appraisals for the Canadian War Museum, Royal Canadian Artillery Museum etc.

START DATEEND DATENAMECOMMENTS
19721978COLIN STEVENSFounder. Moved to a job in Saskatchewan.
19781979Doug WareNo accession records.
19801984NO CURATOR ?
1984 Approx. 1986Rod Smith WWII Seaforth veteran
1986 (late)1991 (early)COLIN STEVENSMoved back from Sask. up Fraser Valley.
19911997UNKNOWN - Possibly LCol E. Rod Vance
19981999 ?LCol (ret) E. ROD VANCE
1999 ?2002Jim BathhurstDied 2002
? 2006Don Parr-PearsonDied 2006. laptop with museum records was stolen.
20062008 FebruaryLCol E. Rod VanceDie Feb. 2008
2008 April2011 July Approx. COLIN STEVENSRetired.

THE FIRST SEARCH OF THE ARMOURY

In 1971, Soviet Premier Kosygin visited Vancouver. I was already using the Fan Room (above what was later named the Anderson Room and below the attic) to organize items that I had found. to start a museum. A B.C. Telephone technician had to string some wires through the attic for extra security lines regarding the visit I believe. As he poked his head through the attic ceiling hatch, and shone his flashlight around, two glowing cougar eyes greeted him!  After that I went up into the attic many times and emptied out the machine guns, 1918 Schmeisser MP-18 I SMG, Snider Enfield rifles,  Mauser Gew98 rifle, Snider Cadet Carbines, framed pictures, stacks of WWII cardboard pith helmets, and a painting showing Smokey Smith winning the Victoria Cross etc.

One of the most interesting items I found was the following. “Pennant flag, Hammer and Sickle. Russian 1917 (Does not have the five pointed star which signified the 5 continents the Bolsheviks [Communists] planned to conquer. The star [was] added in 1918 so that dates this flag before that date. Captured by Canadians at Orosozeros in Russia, near Murmansk c. 1919 Probably the ONLY Soviet flag captured in battle by Canadians therefore nationally significant.” As a result, the museum traded to the Canadian War Museum.

Stuffed cougar used for recruiting and in Sgts Mess found in attic
Stuffed cougar used for recruiting and in Sgts Mess found in attic

 

SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT

An article was published by CBC RADIO on 2016-09-24 entitled “Preserving history one shoebox at a time at the Seaforth Armoury.” Current Curator Rob MacDonald was interviewed. The information that was presented was full of errors, was extremely misleading and was extremely insulting to the many of us who had worked in the museum and archives for decades. The article implies that the museum is just being started by MacDonald and that he found that everything was in chaos.

  1. MacDonald was quoted as saying: “Before the armoury’s renovation started, Seaforth Highlanders Museum staff and volunteers scoured the building for historic material squirrelled away by soldiers.   Archivists packed four truckloads of art, photos and artifacts for documentation. Many of the boxes found had never been opened before.” FACTS: The article implies that the museum is a new feature and no mention is made of its long existence. There are well established and organized files, a huge Database Accession Register of over 7,270 items that I created and to which others contributed. I also created an SOP MANUAL (Standard Operating Procedures) for the operation of the museum and archives. The Seaforth Archives were started well before 1946. The Seaforth Museum was started by me in 1972 and it is now an official Canadian Forces Museum as of 2003, thanks to the hard work of the many volunteers (including my wife Jeanette) over the decades.  I searched the armoury in 1971-1972 and that was when the bulk of the items were discovered, things that were hidden away in closets, back rooms, the basement and the attic. I do agree that it was a good idea to search the armoury again when the unit moved out in 2012, as a few more items would surface, but it was not, as the article implies, the first time that this had happened.
  2. The article said: ” The titles listed on thousands of shoe boxes, crates and even pizza boxes often don’t match what is inside.”  FACTS: This is blatantly untrue. NO pizza boxes were ever used and as far as I know, no shoeboxes were used either. The vast majority of the museum and archives boxes were numbered and labelled with their contents. We used R-Kive Banker Boxes, and as and when the very small budget permitted, acid free boxes for archival material.
  3. The article went on to say: ” MacDonald says this tobacco tin was carried by a private during the Battle of Regina Trench. He says Private Lord was hit by two rounds from a machine gun but escaped injury thanks to his tin. Lord carried the tin until the end of the First World War as a lucky talisman and never smoked the tobacco inside.” FACTS: This so-called history is fiction. The present Curator has obviously not consulted the Museum Accession Register or museum files, as he has confused two different artifacts from two different donors and then had added fictional aspects to the story. I collected this bullet pierced cigarette tin and the accompanying bullet pierced Field Message Book in 1972 for the museum. From the Museum Accession Register that I created: 1972.22.2 “Tin, cigarette, 50, Player’s, with bullet hole, Captain McIntosh. Carried by Captain McIntosh. Story collected at the time (1972) that he went “over the top” in WWI with message book in one pocket of his tunic and cigarette tin in other pocket and that a German machinegun [was] shooting at them. He was between the bullets – one bullet passing through each tunic lower pocket and its contents.”  Also in the collection is a Brodie helmet (WWI British “Tommy” helmet) and shrapnel ball from Mr. Arthur Lord, accession numbers 1974.7.1A & .1B. I collected these from this WWI veteran directly. Here is the Accession Register entry I created for that. “Helmet, shrapnel, steel, “Brodie” pattern. WWI, with very rare khaki cloth cover, marked “A.L. 72 and serial#.  No liner. Damaged when loaned [lent] to R West R for a home movie in 1970s. Arthur Lord letter on file: “Bullet [sic. it is actually a shrapnel ball] + My Tin Hat   Name – Arthur Lord    Regimental No. 129630     Batt. 72nd Seaforth — On the 31st October 1916 we were stationed in the Regina Trench on the Somme and at about 4 PM , raining and getting dark, the Germans sent over shrapnels and they hit me with this Shrapnel Bullet, but luckily for me, I was wearing my Tin Hat and the bullet hit same turning up [sic – it actually turned down] the edge, before entering the right side by my Jugular vein. Sure saved my life (he underlined the previous 4 words) I was lucky once again, feeling sick from loss of blood and making my way back on foot to the Sunken Road over no mans (sic) land, as I passed lots of Dead Soldiers.    From there I was put on a 4 Mule limber to the Bapaume Road and then by ambulance to Albert for injections, and at midnight 40 miles in another ambulance to Hospital where they took out the Bullet from my neck and that evening I was on my way on a Stretcher by Hospital Train to “Boulogne” Hospital and then in about 3 weeks over the channel to “Blighty.”  (signed) Arthur Lord 129630.” Note for the record. The shrapnel ball was kept with the helmet in the same cardboard storage box and the ball is in a 35mm film canister as I recall. The cloth cover was replaced by Arthur Lord after the shrapnel ball hit as the canvas was not cut where the ball hit. The name “GIBBS” inked inside the helmet and this was damage done when some idiot lent a bunch of museum artifacts to the Royal Westminster Regiment. Lt. Gibbs wrote his name in felt pen inside each borrowed helmet!
  4. ” Newly discovered pieces help document the history of the regiment in ways military records cannot.” The example MacDonald used is a kilt apron with the signatures of soldiers in a sub-unit of the 72nd. FACTS: The fact is that most, if not all, of these items were “discovered” decades ago and recorded in the Accession Register. NOTE: Non-Public Property such as in the Messes was never under the Museum. The Sergeant’s Mess and Junior Ranks Club appropriated artifacts (firearms, large cast metal eagle and swastika etc.) from the Museum collection with no apparent permission as no records were found of loans. Indeed the President of the Mess Committee for the Sergeant’s Mess refused to allow the Museum Curator to inventory these museum artifacts (circa 2010-2011) Yes, there is indeed value in researching the names on these kilt aprons, when time permits. There are many signed kilt aprons in the museum collection including the following kilt aprons:.
    •  1973.65.7    “B” Coy, 72 Bn CEF  1916
    •  1975.13.1    1st Bn. Seaforth of C  1940
    •  1977.12.1A   14 Platoon Bramshot 72nd Highlanders and .1B framed letter explaining what happened to these men.
    •  1977.12.2      Pipe Band 72nd Seaforth Highlanders of Canada 1914-1918
    •  1998.110.1     “Scouts and Snipers”
    •  1998.111.1     “D” Company 1916
    •  1998.112.1      231st Bn CEF
    • and there are others in the Accession Register.